iPad – XT, Vodafone and 2Degrees comparision
Well the iPad is out in NZ now (although the Apple NZ site still shows Notify Me at the top right for where the Order Now button should be as spotted 1st by Lance Wiggs). Anyway, in addition to this meaning that I now won’t get swamped by people when I pull the iPad out in public, it does mean many of the NZ telcos have also released micro sims and also iPad data plans. So here’s the round up.
iPad summary for New Zealand across telcos
For each item, any clear winner is marked in green, with any clear last place network marked in red (blue is for hyperlinks, so ignore that colour!)
2Degrees |
XT (Telecom) |
Vodafone |
|
3G network |
(only have coverage in 50% of NZ) |
Yes, full |
Yes, but not 3G in all of NZ for the iPad1 |
Micro Sims |
Available now | Available now | Available now |
Data Plans(pre-pay) |
$6 for 50MB2 |
500MB – $29.95 (1GB is $59.90) 2GB – $59.95 (4GB is $89.90) 4GB – $79.95 (8GB is $109.90) XT Pre-Pay Data Plans here See note 3 |
250MB – $20 3GB – $50 Vodafone iPad Data Plans here See note 4 |
Data Plans(contract) |
Not yet available |
500MB – $29.95 2GB – $49.95/$59.95 4GB – $69.95/79.95 XT Contract Data Plans here See note 5 |
No idea. Some other voda plans MAY work, but remember some plans are “add ons” only (meaning is has to be added onto an existing Phone Plan, no a stand alone data plan. |
Price of Micro Sim |
Free to swap, or $20 with $20 credit. |
Prepaid $29.95 / Postpaid $19.95 (free on open term 500MB plan) |
Free according to the web site (but $6.95 postage) |
Data charges special conditions |
30 Days Expiry on pre-pay Charges full amount each month when used at all. |
PREPAY: 30 Day expiry for pre-pay. Offers special 10c/MB until hit cap, and also $29.95 in a month to double data CONTRACT: Can do the “double up” for $29.95 (see note 5) |
30 Days Expiry on Pre-Pay Charges full amount each month when used at all. |
Notes
- See this post for why XT is full 3G for the iPad (and iPhone 3Gs/3G) where as Vodafone is not. Or check for yourself by comparing coverage on XT with coverage on Vodafone and coverage on 2Degrees or this speed test between XT and Voda on an iPad in NZ
- 2Degrees data all expires 30 days after purchase. 50c/MB over 50MB.
- XT pre-pay charges 10c per MB capped at rate you set (e.g. if on 2GB then capped at $59.95) Then for a further $29.95 your data doubles (so 2GB goes to 4) and then its 10c/MB after that. These “double up” rates are show in brackets in the table above. All XT rates are the same as other mobile devices. A reminder some plans on XT are add ons only, meaning they can only be added onto an existing phone plan (i.e. not for data only devices like the iPad)
- For Vodafone, these are special iPad only plans. In theory one might be able to use any of Vodafone’s data plans, but their web site implies that these are the only plans avail, so I am listing these only. Remember, like XT, some plans are add ons only, meaning they can only be added onto an existing phone plan (i.e. not for data only devices like the iPad)
- XT rates for 2GB and 4GB contract are reduced by $10 if Home/Business broadband plan. The table above shows this. Also they offer the same “$29.95 for to double data for the month” as they do with Pre-Pay.
My recommendations on plans (updated 26th July 2010)
For light users:
- The 29.95 XT pre-pay plan is best.
- If you only use 20MB, that’s 10cx20 = $2, if you use 100MB, that’s $10, and so on up to 295MB (anything between 295MB and 500MB is $29.95).
For heavy users:
- The XT 2GB plan (on pre-pay or contract, whatever is easier for you). The double up to 4GB for a further $29.95 makes this plan very flexible (and good value). Same apples to the 4GB plan – but I would be hard pressed to use 4GB, let alone 8GB, on an iPad.
- If you insist on Vodafone and are only in the major metros most of the time, their 3GB for $50 plan is quite good, but know that Vodafone does NOT have a 3G network in all of NZ, and that even where it does XT is heaps faster most of the time.
UPDATE 27th July 2010:
Check out my new iPad pricing graphs for data here – it shows all the cross over points right up to 10GB or all pre-pay plans.
Other useful related links
- If you don’t yet quite understand what a Micro Sim is, or want to know more about using one, see this previous post.
- Check out www.iphonewzealand.co.nz – a great resource for iPad / iPhones in NZ
- My full iPad review for Kiwis.
- Why it’s important to be able to covert micro-sims back to normal sized sims (and how to do it!)
Black and White Version: XT is still the way to go for the iPad (better coverage, and better conditions on plans) but at least there is a choice of three carriers now.
Update 26th July 2010: Made some corrections in line comments below – thanks Reuben! Removed some XT casual plans, and updated notes on XT and Voda.
Updated 29th July 2010: Updated 2Degrees info on micro-sim availability and pricing.
My pick would be certainly XT Prepaid:
Nationwide 3G coverage.
Bonus credit on top-ups, makes the prices even lower.
No “forced” voice plan that you can’t use!
The way XT Prepaid charges for data is excellent,
10c per MB until the cap is reached therefore no “up front” commitment if you use less. (200MB is $20, 75 MB is $7.50 and it’s only charged per KB and rounded to the nearest cent.